Econometric evidence on the depreciation of innovations
Gaétan de Rassenfosse, Adam B. Jaffe
European Economic Review (2018), 101: 625-642
Research Question
What is the depreciation rate of innovations and how does patent protection affect it?
Why Do We Care
The depreciation rate of innovations is critical for understanding the long-term value of intangible assets, particularly in knowledge economies where investment in research and development is significant. Previous studies have often relied on indirect methods with strong identifying assumptions, leading to uncertain and potentially biased estimates of these rates. Accurate measurements of innovation depreciation are essential for both economic modeling and policymaking, as they inform decisions related to R&D investments, patent strategies, and overall economic growth.
What Did We Do
Using data from the Australian Inventor Survey consisting of 2,259 patent applications filed between 1986 and 2005, we estimate the depreciation rate of innovations by directly observing revenue streams rather than relying on indirect inference. These data allow us to estimate the relationship between innovation age, patent status, and associated revenues using regression models, including OLS and generalized linear models.
What Did We Find
We find that the depreciation rate of innovations is estimated to be between 2% and 7%, depending on model specifications and the macroeconomic environment. We also find that inventions granted a patent exhibit a reduction in depreciation rates of approximately 1 to 2 percentage points compared to those without patent protection. Additionally, our estimates suggest a consistent connection between patent protection and slower revenue erosion, challenging previous literature that did not find a clear distinction between depreciation rates based on R&D expenditures versus patent status.
Primary Data
- Australian Inventor Survey (AIS) with 2259 patent applications and 2558 inventions having associated value data
Assumptions
- The depreciation rate is constant over time
- Patent protection affects the depreciation rate of innovations
- Observations from the survey represent a reliable sample of the overall population of innovations