Rules of engagement: measuring connectivity in national systems of higher education

Gaétan de Rassenfosse, Ross Williams

Higher Education (2015), 70(6): 941-956

Research Question

How do different national systems of higher education exhibit connectivity with society both domestically and internationally?

Why Do We Care

With the sizable investment of national resources into higher education, there is a growing expectation for universities to fulfill a variety of societal roles beyond traditional teaching and research. Understanding how well universities connect with their broader communities, both domestically and internationally, sheds light on their impact on economic growth and societal development. This connectivity can stimulate the transfer of knowledge, collaboration with industries, and engagement with local communities—making it essential for informed policy-making and funding decisions in higher education.

What Did We Do

We employed a comparative analysis of the connectivity of 50 national higher education systems using ten indicators, focusing on both domestic and international connectivity. These data were gathered from a variety of sources, including the IMD World Competitiveness Rankings, World Economic Forum surveys, and CWTS-Leiden data on collaborative publications. The sample comprised countries selected based on their national research performance, with a deliberate inclusion of G20 nations, while ensuring robust data quality.

What Did We Find

We found that smaller countries tend to have higher levels of international connectivity compared to larger nations. Specifically, countries like Ireland, Switzerland, and Singapore rank high on connectivity measures, while the USA, China, and Japan have more insular education systems relative to their size. Moreover, among lower-income nations, South Africa is noted for its effective connectivity in higher education. These findings are significant as they highlight how national characteristics influence the effectiveness of higher education engagement with wider societal demands.

Primary Data

  • IMD Business Competitiveness Survey (2013) with responses from business executives on knowledge transfer
  • World Economic Forum (2013-2014) survey on university-business collaboration, with data across multiple countries
  • CWTS-Leiden data (2008-2010) on joint university-industry publications, detailing both domestic and international collaborations, for 50 countries

Assumptions

  • The indicators selected for measuring connectivity accurately reflect the broader engagement of universities with external societal actors
  • Responses in surveys represent an accurate portrayal of the perceived connectivity between universities and industry
  • The countries included in the analysis provide reliable data that reflect their actual higher education performance